Skip to content

The Bridge Murder: The 1929 Bennett Case Explained

In 1929 a Kansas City wife shot her husband after a hand of contract bridge, and a jury found her not guilty. The real story of the bridge murder, the myths, and the famous hand behind it.

·

Part of our famous bridge stories series: true tales of scandal, crime and great matches from the world of bridge.

The bridge murder is the most famous story in the history of the game. On the night of 29 September 1929, in a flat in Kansas City, Myrtle Bennett shot and killed her husband John after an argument over a hand of contract bridge. A jury later found her not guilty, and the case became a national sensation just as bridge was sweeping America.

Almost a century on, the bridge murder is still retold, often with the details muddled. Here’s what happened, based on the contemporary trial reports, with the myths sorted from the facts and a look at the hand itself.

The evening of the bridge murder

John G. Bennett was a 36-year-old perfume salesman, and Myrtle had been his wife since 1918. On Sunday 29 September 1929 they spent the day playing golf with their neighbours Charles and Mayme Hofman, who lived in the same building on Ward Parkway. (Some later accounts call her Myrna, but the earliest detailed account names her Mayme.) That evening the four sat down to play contract bridge for tiny stakes: a tenth of a cent a side.

Late in the evening came the hand that ended it all. John dealt and opened 1♠. Charles Hofman bid 2♦, and Myrtle jumped straight to 4♠, making John the declarer and herself the dummy. The most detailed contemporary account says Hofman doubled; others leave the double out. John went two down. If terms like declarer and dummy are new to you, our list of bridge terms explains them.

As dummy, Myrtle had gone to the kitchen to make John’s breakfast for a business trip the next morning. When the hand was over, the argument began.

The argument

John blamed Myrtle for overbidding, and she called him a “bum bridge player”. According to the witnesses, he slapped her several times. In the account written by the critic Alexander Woollcott from the trial reports, she said: “No one but a cur would strike a woman in the presence of friends.” Later retellings change “cur” to “bum” and alter the wording, which is one reason the story has so many versions.

Myrtle went to her mother’s bedroom and came back with a .32 automatic pistol.

Four shots were fired. The first went through a bathroom door and the second hit the frame above it. The third and fourth struck John, and the fourth, in the back, killed him.

The trial

The bridge murder trial began on 23 February 1931, some 17 months later, and lasted 11 days. Myrtle was defended by James A. Reed, a former United States senator and one of the best-known courtroom lawyers in the country.

The defence’s case was that the bridge murder wasn’t murder at all, but an accident. Myrtle said she had been fetching the gun because John wanted it for his trip, that she stumbled over a chair and the first two shots went off by mistake, and that the fatal shots were fired as he tried to take the gun from her. Reed also told the jury about John’s treatment of her. Some important evidence for the prosecution wasn’t allowed.

The jury took about eight hours to find her not guilty, and the bridge murder became more talked about than ever. One of the prosecutors remarked that it looked like “an open season on husbands”. According to Woollcott, her insurance company later paid her $30,000 on John’s accident policy.

Myths about the bridge murder

Because the bridge murder has been retold so often, plenty of versions get it wrong:

  • “She was acquitted because he played the hand badly.” No. The jury accepted that the shooting was an accident.
  • “She fired a single shot.” There were four.
  • “Myrtle was the declarer.” Every reliable account makes John the declarer and Myrtle the dummy.
  • “Culbertson gave evidence at the trial.” Nothing in the trial records supports this.
  • “This is the real hand.” See below. The deal usually printed is a reconstruction.

The bridge murder hand

The people at the table couldn’t remember the exact cards, which had been scattered in the commotion. Newspapers asked experts, including Sidney Lenz, to work out what might have happened, and one deal has been printed ever since. Several bridge writers regard it as a fabrication, so treat it as a famous reconstruction rather than a record. Here it is, with John as South and Myrtle as North.

North (Myrtle, dummy)

♠ A 10 6 3
♥ 10 8 5
♦ 4
♣ A 9 8 4 2

West (Charles Hofman)

♠ Q 7 2
♥ A J 3
♦ A Q 10 9 2
♣ J 6

East (Mayme Hofman)

♠ 4
♥ Q 9 4
♦ K J 7 6 3
♣ Q 7 5 3

South (John, declarer and dealer)

♠ K J 9 8 5
♥ K 7 6 2
♦ 8 5
♣ K 10

West led the ace of diamonds and switched to the jack of clubs. John won with the king and started on trumps, guessed wrong in spades, and lost tricks in hearts. Ely Culbertson later wrote that he should have ruffed his last diamond in dummy first, then set up dummy’s clubs to throw away his losing hearts. Other analysts have since argued that a diamond continuation at trick two beats the contract anyway, so the debate about the bridge murder hand has never quite ended.

Would you open John’s hand today?

Probably not. John held 10 high card points with five spades and four hearts. In Acol, a popular guide for a light opening is the Rule of 20: add your points to the number of cards in your two longest suits, and open if the total is 20 or more. John’s hand comes to 10 + 5 + 4 = 19, one short. Try a few hands of your own with our Rule of 20 quiz.

Myrtle’s jump to 4♠ with 8 points was ambitious too, though four-card support and a singleton make it less wild than it looks.

What happened next

Ely Culbertson wrote up the bridge murder in his new magazine, The Bridge World, and told audiences that John might have lived if the couple had played his system. The publicity did bridge no harm at all, and seven years later Agatha Christie made a bridge evening the scene of a fictional murder in Cards on the Table. Within two years Culbertson was playing the most famous match of the era, which you can read about in Culbertson Lenz, the Bridge Battle of the Century.

Woollcott’s essay on the case, published in 1934, ends with a story about Myrtle having understandable difficulty finding a partner afterwards. She never remarried, worked for many years as head of housekeeping at a New York hotel, kept playing bridge, and died in Miami in 1992, aged 96. The journalist Gary Pomerantz told the full story, alongside the Culbertsons’, in his 2009 book The Devil’s Tickets.

The lesson for every partnership

Every bridge player has felt a flash of irritation at partner. The bridge murder is an extreme reminder that the post-mortem is where partnerships go wrong. Talk about a hand calmly, later, and never in front of the opponents. Our guides to unwritten rules of the bridge club and bridge etiquette cover how good partners do it, and the game has other famous dramas in our guide to bridge cheating scandals.

If you’d like to learn bridge online in a friendly way, with no shouting, every bridge course in our six-step pathway is a recording of Chris’s live classes, and every lesson has a free preview.

Frequently asked questions

What was the bridge murder?

The bridge murder was the 1929 killing of John G. Bennett by his wife Myrtle in Kansas City, after an argument over a hand of contract bridge they had just played with their neighbours. She was tried in 1931 and found not guilty.

Why was Myrtle Bennett found not guilty?

Her lawyer, the former senator James A. Reed, argued that the shooting was an accident: she had been fetching the gun for John’s trip and it went off as she stumbled and as he tried to take it from her. The jury accepted that defence after about eight hours.

What was the bridge hand in the Bennett murder?

John opened 1♠, Charles Hofman overcalled 2♦, and Myrtle raised to 4♠, which John played and went two down. The full deal usually printed is a reconstruction, because the players could not remember the exact cards.

What happened to Myrtle Bennett?

She never remarried, worked as head of housekeeping at a New York hotel, continued to play bridge, and died in Miami in 1992 at the age of 96.

Is there a book about the bridge murder?

Yes. Gary Pomerantz’s The Devil’s Tickets (2009) tells the story alongside that of Ely and Josephine Culbertson. Alexander Woollcott’s 1934 essay on the case, written from the trial reports, is the main contemporary account.

Ready to learn Bridge properly?

Our courses are the full recordings of Chris’s popular live Zoom classes - yours to watch, pause and rewatch at your own pace. Six steps take you from complete beginner to competitive duplicate, and no partner is needed.

Follow Learn To Play Bridge Online on Pinterest

Free download

Get the cheat sheet

Enter your email and the PDF opens straight away. We will also email you the link, and every other free sheet on the site unlocks for you too.

We never share your email. See our privacy policy.