Has anyone ever cheated at bridge?
Yes. Bridge has seen several proven cheating scandals at the very top of the game. The most infamous is the 1965 Buenos Aires affair, when British stars Terence Reese and Boris Schapiro were accused of signalling how many hearts they held by the way they held their cards. A wave of card-placement and coughing scandals then followed between 2013 and 2016.
The reassuring part, and the part that matters most if you are learning, is that these cases involved a tiny number of world-class professionals playing for money and titles. They are famous precisely because they are so rare. At the friendly club and social level where most of us play, bridge runs on trust, good manners and a genuinely welcoming spirit.
What happened in the 1965 Buenos Aires bridge scandal?
The Buenos Aires Incident is the most notorious cheating affair in the history of the game, and it involved two of Britain’s greatest players. At the 1965 Bermuda Bowl world championship in Buenos Aires, England’s Terence Reese and Boris Schapiro were accused of using the number of fingers they showed while holding their cards to signal the number of hearts in their hand.
The accusation was raised by American players B. Jay Becker and Dorothy Hayden, and other observers agreed something was amiss. Britain’s non-playing captain, Ralph Swimer, conceded the team’s remaining matches rather than fight on under a cloud. What followed was one of sport’s strangest split verdicts. The World Bridge Federation found the pair guilty of cheating. Yet the British Bridge League’s own inquiry reached the opposite conclusion, finding that “Messrs. Reese and Schapiro were not guilty of cheating at the Tournament in question”.
Reese, a celebrated author and theorist, defended himself in a book called “Story of an Accusation”, while the English-born New York Times bridge columnist Alan Truscott set out the case against them in “The Great Bridge Scandal”. Reese maintained his innocence for the rest of his life, and to this day the affair has never been fully settled. It remains the case every bridge player has heard of. We tell the whole story, using the inquiry’s own published report, in our page on the Buenos Aires affair.
Were there other cheating cases in the older days of bridge?
Yes, a handful of cases surfaced across the twentieth century, usually at international level where the stakes were highest.
- 1975, the foot-tapping case. At the Bermuda Bowl in Bermuda, the Italian pair Gianfranco Facchini and Sergio Zucchelli were accused of tapping feet under the table. A committee reprimanded them for improper conduct, but did not find it proven that the taps had carried information.
- 1979, the pencil case. American players Steve Sion and Alan Cokin were found to have signalled their hand shape using the placement of a pencil. Both confessed, and they were barred from play.
These older cases share a theme with the modern ones. Because partners are not allowed to pass private information, would-be cheats have always reached for something ordinary at the table - fingers, a foot, a pencil, a card - and turned it into a secret code.
What was the 2013 “coughing” bridge scandal?
At the 2013 World Bridge Championships in Bali, the German pair Michael Elinescu and Entscho Wladow were accused of exchanging information by coughing during the final of the seniors event. In 2014 the World Bridge Federation found them guilty, banned them from playing together for life and imposed ten-year individual bans. The story did lead to a legal aftermath: in 2017 a German court set aside the federation sanctions on legal grounds, a reminder that these disputes can rumble on for years in the courts as well as at the card table.
What caused the 2015 bridge cheating scandals?
In the summer of 2015 the game was rocked by an extraordinary run of exposures, driven largely by one man. The Norwegian international Boye Brogeland grew suspicious after a knock-out loss, studied the recorded broadcast records of top matches, and began publicly presenting evidence against several leading professional pairs. Within weeks, some of the biggest names in the game were under investigation, and the wider public learned just how much elite play is now filmed and archived. Our page on how the 2015 bridge cheats were caught tells the detective story case by case, with every later ruling.
Fisher and Schwartz
The Israeli pair Lotan Fisher and Ron Schwartz were found to have signalled by the way they placed the board on the table between the bidding and the play. The American Contract Bridge League found them guilty of collusive cheating and expelled them, the Israeli federation permanently banned them, and the European Bridge League barred the partnership for life.
Fantoni and Nunes
The Italian pair Fulvio Fantoni and Claudio Nunes were accused of orienting a card during the opening lead to show whether they held a high honour in the suit. Several bodies, including the American and European leagues, initially found them guilty and banned them. This case, however, carries an important qualification. In January 2018 the Court of Arbitration for Sport upheld the pair’s appeal, ruling that the case had not been proven to the required standard - while stressing that this did not mean the players were innocent, only that the infraction had not been established to the panel’s comfortable satisfaction. The Italian federation cancelled its own ban later in 2018, and the American Contract Bridge League’s expulsion has not been reported lifted.
Piekarek and Smirnov
The German pair Josef Piekarek and Alexander Smirnov admitted arranging a secret code, using the placement of their bidding cards on the tray to indicate the strength of their hands. They confessed after being confronted with evidence. The European Bridge League banned the partnership for life and imposed a multi-year individual ban.
How is cheating prevented in top-level bridge today?
Championship bridge has taken the threat seriously for decades. Long before these scandals, the game introduced bridge screens - a diagonal barrier placed across the table so that you cannot see your own partner, only your two opponents. That single measure removes a huge amount of the body language cheats once relied upon. On top of screens, top events use video review, careful monitoring, and statistical analysis of results, and online play leaves a detailed record that can be examined afterwards. Ironically, the very thoroughness of modern record-keeping is what allowed the 2015 cases to be caught.
What about cheating in online bridge?
When the pandemic moved serious bridge online in 2020, a small number of players, some of them well known, were caught “self-kibitzing”: logging in a second account to watch their own table and see all four hands. Several admitted it and were suspended, and the national and international federations set up dedicated online ethics teams. Because every card played online is recorded, cheats are easier to catch by statistics than they ever were at the table. Our guide to online bridge cheating explains how it’s spotted, what the main sites do and how to report a concern privately.
Should ordinary club and social players worry about this?
Honestly, no. Every scandal above involved a small group of elite professionals competing for world titles and prize money, which is a world away from a friendly afternoon at the local club. Ordinary bridge is one of the most sociable and good-natured games there is, built on courtesy and a shared love of a clever hand. Nobody is coughing in code at your Tuesday session. And if you enjoy true tales from the game, there are plenty more in our famous bridge stories, from the 1929 bridge murder to a James Bond grand slam. If anything, these stories are a comfort: they show how strongly the bridge world defends fair play, and how seriously it treats the rare cases that arise.
Learn bridge the friendly, honest way
If reading about the drama has made you curious to play, you are in good company - a scandal is often what draws newcomers to discover what a wonderful game bridge really is. Our recorded courses take you from your very first hand through to confident club play, taught in plain English by Chris Mower, an EBTA-accredited teacher. They are recordings of Chris’s real Zoom classes, so you learn the proper British Acol system - weak no-trump, Stayman, transfers and all - at your own pace, replaying anything you like. No signals, no secret codes, just clear, patient teaching and a warm welcome to the game.
Frequently asked questions
Has anyone ever cheated at bridge?
Yes. Bridge has had several documented cheating scandals at world-championship level. The most famous is the 1965 Buenos Aires affair involving British players Terence Reese and Boris Schapiro, followed by a cluster of card-placement and coughing scandals between 2013 and 2016. These cases are notorious precisely because cheating at the top of the game is so rare.
What was the 1965 Buenos Aires bridge scandal?
At the 1965 Bermuda Bowl in Buenos Aires, British stars Terence Reese and Boris Schapiro were accused of signalling how many hearts they held by the number of fingers showing as they held their cards. The World Bridge Federation found them guilty, but a British Bridge League inquiry found them not guilty. The case has never been fully resolved.
How did the 2015 bridge cheating scandals come to light?
The Norwegian international Boye Brogeland led the exposures in 2015. He studied the recorded broadcast records of top matches and publicly presented evidence against several leading professional pairs. His work triggered investigations that ended the careers of several world-class partnerships.
What is the “coughing” bridge scandal?
At the 2013 World Bridge Championships in Bali, German pair Michael Elinescu and Entscho Wladow were accused of exchanging information by coughing. The World Bridge Federation found them guilty in 2014 and banned the partnership for life. A German court later set aside those sanctions on legal grounds.
Were Fantoni and Nunes found guilty of cheating?
They were initially found guilty and banned by several bridge bodies after being accused of signalling honours through the orientation of a played card. However, in January 2018 the Court of Arbitration for Sport upheld their appeal, ruling the case had not been proven to the required standard. The court stressed this did not declare them innocent, only that the infraction was not established to its satisfaction.
How is cheating prevented in top-level bridge?
Championship bridge uses screens, a diagonal barrier across the table that stops partners seeing each other, together with video review, monitoring and statistical analysis of results. Online play also leaves a detailed record that can be examined afterwards. These measures make organised cheating far harder and easier to detect than in the past.
Do ordinary club and social bridge players cheat?
Virtually never. All the famous scandals involved a small number of elite professionals competing for titles and money. Club and social bridge relies on courtesy, trust and good sportsmanship, and is one of the friendliest games you can play.
Can a beginner learn bridge without worrying about any of this?
Absolutely. Cheating scandals belong to the professional game, not to the club table or the classroom. Our recorded courses teach the British Acol system in plain English with Chris Mower, an EBTA-accredited teacher, so you can learn confidently at your own pace.
